Is EMDR Right for Me? How to Know If EMDR Treatment Would Be Beneficial

Have you ever wondered if you would benefit from EMDR therapy? Primarily used in the treatment of trauma-based mental health conditions, EMDR has successfully treated millions of people worldwide.

However, EMDR is not for everyone. Depending on your individual mental health needs, a clinician might recommend a different treatment modality better suited to your personal challenges and concerns.

So, how do you know if EMDR is right for you? Ultimately, it’s a decision to be made alongside your mental health provider. However, if you’re interested in learning more, keep reading for an overview of how EMDR can help—and when a different modality might be a better fit.

Is EMDR Right for Me

What Is EMDR?

Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is a psychotherapy treatment used to treat trauma-based mental health conditions such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and complex post-traumatic stress disorder (C-PTSD).

It’s recognized by the American Psychiatric Association, the American Psychological Association, the Department of Veterans Affairs, the Substance Abuse & Mental Health Services Administration, and the World Health Organization as an effective treatment for trauma.

Sometimes, when a person goes through a traumatic event, their brain improperly stores the memory in a way that doesn’t allow for healthy healing. Because their brain is not able to heal from the traumatic memory, the brain and body don’t fully understand that they are no longer in danger.

EMDR works to help a patient take these traumatic memories and properly store them in order to alleviate flashbacks and panic symptoms. This is done through reprocessing and bilateral stimulation with the guidance of a clinician trained in EMDR.

For a more thorough breakdown, click here to learn more about the eight phases of EMDR.

Is EMDR Right for Me?

Aspire provider Jason Jones, PhD, notes that while online buzz about EMDR has picked up in recent years, it is far from a new fad. EMDR has been around for nearly 40 years, and is backed by an established body of evidence supporting its effectiveness.

EMDR is primarily used to treat trauma and PTSD. However, it is also used to treat several other conditions.

Some mental health providers use EMDR to treat:

  • Anxiety

  • Panic

  • Depression

  • Eating disorders

  • Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD)

  • Dissociative disorders

  • Personality disorders

In his personal experience as a provider, Dr. Jones says that EMDR can be particularly helpful for patients with PTSD who find themselves feeling emotionally detached and suspect they may be struggling to access their feelings about events in their past. He also adds that EMDR can be beneficial for those who identify as having C-PTSD or who live with trauma symptoms that don’t neatly fit the traditional PTSD diagnosis, such as complex grief, relational challenges, or lingering resentment about the past.

According to Alesin Sinclair, LCSW, one thing she looks for when determining whether EMDR could be beneficial for a patient is whether their emotional responses seem disproportionate to what is happening in the present. She notes that exploring these reactions can reveal earlier lived experiences that continue to influence how the patient responds to relationships, conflict, criticism, or perceived rejection. 

When Is a Different Treatment a Better Option?

For some mental health conditions, EMDR is not the right choice. EMDR specifically works with conditions related to trauma or traumatic experiences, so it is not helpful for patients struggling as a result of an inherited condition or injury.

EMDR should not be utilized if you are currently in an active crisis, as its purpose is to reprocess events and memories that have already happened in the past. It also is not the right choice for patients experiencing psychosis, as it’s crucial that patients are able to differentiate between past memories and present reality.

Patients who are actively suicidal or experiencing suicidal ideation are also not the right fit for EMDR, as certain phases of EMDR can heighten and intensify emotions. It is best for patients to stabilize first as opposed to introducing new, strong emotions in need of regulation.

Is EMDR Right for Me?

If you are living with trauma or other mental health conditions that have been shown to be treated by EMDR, it’s worth having a conversation with your mental health provider to see if EMDR could be beneficial for you.

As Sinclair points out, “Understanding a pattern doesn’t necessarily change it. A client may recognize where a response comes from but continue to experience the same reactions in daily life. When past experiences appear to be contributing to those responses, EMDR may be worth considering as part of the treatment plan.”

She also says that it’s important to work alongside your provider to determine the right pacing throughout EMDR treatment. Patients who tend to shut down, dissociate, disconnect, or lose awareness of the present, for example, may need more preparation or a modified pace before beginning reprocessing.

“For me, readiness isn't just about a client's willingness to address the past,” says Sinclair. “It's also about their ability to stay present, manage activation, and recover after difficult material comes up. Knowing when to proceed with reprocessing and when to spend more time on preparation is an important part of the work.”

EMDR in Portland Oregon

EMDR Treatment in Portland, Oregon

Curious if EMDR could be the right treatment option for you? At Aspire Psychology, our compassionate team of therapists would love to support you as you work toward freedom from traumatic memories and related symptoms.

EMDR is currently offered at Aspire Psychology by Dr. Jason Jones, Alesin Sinclair, and Dr. Victoria Ward. Contact us today to learn more.

Next
Next

CBT vs. DBT: What’s the Difference?